Skill Crossroads crap-analysis
rubric v1.2 · deterministic
B 86.2/100 overall
Correctness & Structure 100 pass
Triggering & Discoverability 85 1 warn
Clarity & Instructions 75 1 warn
Token & Context Cost 91 1 warn
Safety & Security 100 pass
Verifiability & Maintainability 53 1 fail

Top fixes — ranked by score impact

VERIFY-01 Evals or tests present
SKILL.md:1the skill works no evals/, tests/, or verification section found
No way to prove the skill does what it claims.
Fix Add an evals/ folder (test prompts + expected outcomes) and a '## Verify' step in the body.
TRIGGER-03 Invocation cues in the description
SKILL.md:1description will match user requests no explicit cue ('use when …', 'triggers on …', quoted user phrases) found
Pure what-it-does prose — the model has to guess when to invoke it.
Analyze code coverage and CRAP (Change Risk Anti-Patterns) scores to identify…
Fix State the trigger explicitly: 'Use when the user says "…", "…", or wants to …'.
TOKEN-02 Progressive disclosure
SKILL.mdeverything inlined in SKILL.md 384 body lines, 0 supporting files
Large SKILL.md (384 lines) with no supporting files — all of it loads every time the skill fires.
Fix Move heavy reference material into supporting files and link to them, so the model loads it only when needed.
CLARITY-03 No ASCII-art / persona filler
SKILL.md:191
Decorative ASCII-art / banner line — pure token cost, no instructional value.
─────────────
SKILL.md:193
Decorative ASCII-art / banner line — pure token cost, no instructional value.
──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Fix Delete decorative banners and persona filler; keep instructions plain and imperative.
★ scores higher than ≈16% of 208 public skills (deterministic rubric v1.2 sample, 2026-09)

Embed this badge

Skill Crossroads grade B Always-fresh — it re-scans and updates on its own.
[![Skill Crossroads](https://skillcrossroads.com/api/badge/ComeOnOliver/skillshub/skills/Aaronontheweb/dotnet-skills/crap-analysis.svg)](https://skillcrossroads.com/s/ComeOnOliver/skillshub/skills/Aaronontheweb/dotnet-skills/crap-analysis)
Grade your own Claude Code skill — evidence-cited, file-and-line, free. Scan your own skill →